Document Actions

Wind in my sails

by Ed posted on 08-13-2006 00:55 last modified 12-21-2006 08:00 —

Editorial Rating: 1 2 3 4 5 Reader Rating: 1 2 3 4 5 ( 0 votes)
Click to change your reader rating: (not rated)   worthless bad average good great
For a person so used to instant gratification, this project has been the ultimate test in patience. Each and every step forward is a little miracle unto itself and it makes you appreciate everything else that has been accomplished, albeit, very slowly. And after drifting around the Sargasso Sea of virtually suspended animation for the better part of a year, I can finally feel the Gulf Stream at my back. Albeit, with a hurricane or two tossed in for good measure. Don't you just love weather analogies?

In a nutshell, a corner is being turned. The trigger has been pulled and we're off. Being weathered in (well, at least 99% weathered in) is such an incredibly satisfying achievement, especially since it has taken so long and has been fraught with so many setbacks. Considering that all of the trades and components have been staged for completion, the challenge now will be to prevent all of the horses from tripping over each other in the mad dash to the finish line.

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

(NO LONGER) CURTAILED BY CURTAIN WALL PT. III

After dumping Curtain Wall Clown Number 1, I almost felt like Wile E. Coyote running off of a cliff- it felt good at first, but then, when the gravity of what I had done hit me, I started to freefall into a sort of panic state. What am I gonna do now? Can I order curtain wall in a box from Acme? What impact will this have on the project? Will I even be able to find someone to take over? If I do, will they charge an arm and a leg (i.e., union)?

So what does one do when he runs out of options? He turns to the Blue Book and starts letting the fingers do the walking, that's what.

I must have cold-called literally 40 glazing contractors located between Westhampton and Brooklyn- the vast majority, as expected, were strictly commercial or strictly union. I must have sent drawings/pictures/elevations to 20 of them. About 10 of them went out to visit the site. About 3 of them provided written proposals. At one extreme, the proposal to finish the job was actually MORE expensive than the total cost of the job by Curtwain Wall Clown Number 1! The others fell within a wide spread ($25K!) under that.

Ultimately, out of the gazillion contractors I contacted, it really only came down to one- a small father-son glazing contracting business located in Jackson Heights, Queens. The young son in particular was especially taken with the design of the Greenbelt house and seemed very enthusiastic about having the opportunity to add it to his portfolio of projects. And based on some of the other work they did for businesses in the outer boroughs as well as Manhattan (including a wonderful modern penthouse triplex on a rooftop on Warren St. in TriBeCa that I had always admired [that was owned by that CEO in that drug stock scandal that wasn't "a good thing."- hint, hint]), I felt like they had the right mindset and pedigree to do this. And not only was the proposal very reasonable, their specialty was on custom-fabricating everything precisely to spec. And you can't put a price tag on enthusiasm; there's nothing worse than being treated like you're just another McCustomer doing just another McJob.

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

Less than a month after signing the dotted line, things started happening- most of the operable window units and all four of the sliding doors and the front door frame were installed. I was very pleased, especially by the sliders, which were anodized alumninum on both the inside and outside, and had super, super-narrow profiles. Tres chic!

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

However, as you can see, the door hardware was, for all intents and purposes, major-league FUG. They are presently scouring their catalogs and online resources to find something decent. I provided them with an Omnia door leverset which they are going to try to marry up with the lock/mortise mechanism in the door just in case they were not able to find something decent.

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

Last to go up were the #$%!$% triangle end gables in the roof, which required on-site glass pane fabrication since these were all odd trianglular/polygonal shapes. Quite fascinating to watch. After repeatedly taking precise measurements of lengths and angles, templates of each glazing section were made. Then they scored large sheets of glass along the templates that were then snapped perfectly along the score with a strategic tap at just the right location and intensity (apparently this is a bit of an art). After thorough cleansing, the cut glass panes were bonded to metal channels/gaskets, evacuated and sealed with some kind of a suction machine. Almost immediately they were ready to be popped into the curtain wall frame.

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

FIRE IN THE HOLE

After bouncing around a bunch of ideas about how to plug that big hole in the living room curtain wall for the fireplace, we just decided to do the most straightforward thing- a masonry box. And in my classic display of overkill, I ordered a monster of a fireplace (Lennox Col-3629) that necessitated a monster of a masonry box. Ron the builder thinks it looks awful, but I kind of like the scale of it- in a jail cell for dwarfs kind of way.

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

LOST IN TRANSITION

After waiting six months for my Duravit bath fixture order to be fabricated and shipped from Germany, the delivery date was set. I was like a kid on Christmas Eve waiting for the delivery truck like I was waiting for St. Nick himself. Rather than visions of sugar plums dancing, I saw myself plowing through the boxes, one-by-one, to take in all of the modern Euro-fabulosity. Box upon box upon box upon box of it. But when the delivery finally arrived, I quickly surmized that a lot of it was missing. A sh*tload, even. I basically received one of the tubs and a bunch of odds-and-ends and fittings. So where was all the cool schwag??? Wherefore the Starck X basin? The "In the Mood" vanity?? I called "that online e-tailer" to ask why over half of my order was missing (and arguably the cooler half!). Apparently my shipment should have arrived on two skids, but I only received one. Therefore, the second skid must have been left behind somewhere. Unfortunately that "somewhere" could have been any one of the bazillion freight hubs between the midwest and Long Island. To complicate matters, large freight like this may change carriers multiple times after it leaves its point of origination. So the search was on… in every port and dock between Chicago and Boston. Alas, after a couple of weeks and a couple of false positives, the trail finally went dead cold for the second skid around Indianapolis. It was almost, without a doubt, sent to someone else by mistake. It was officially branded "MIA" at this point.

All we know is that someone, somewhere out in the hinterlands of red state America, inadvertently received a large shipment of expensive merchandise that did not belong to them. It's time to 'fess up, whoever you are. It's times like this that I really question humanity, integrity and the goodwill of people. Yes, I have been checking in on eBay to see if any of my stuff ended up there.

Anyway, "that e-tailer" has committed to fulfilling the order by any means possible, but some of it will take another six months to order from Germany. Schießen Sie mich!

"CRACK IS WACK!"

The other day while I was checking on things I noticed that the front Superior Wall under the balcony had a hairline crack running through it. Top to bottom.

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

Hmmm… Then I noticed another hairline crack running… top to bottom… Then I noticed yet another hairline crack. Hmmm…

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

Immediately I remembered that two HVAC supplies were run through the recesses of this section of wall. In fact, the HVAC contractor went through the backbreaking effort of breaking through the concrete header/footer between the basement and first floor, as well as the concrete header to the second floor:

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

I suspected immediately that the herculean force used to create these passages most likely caused these cracks to form over time. We took pictures and immediately had Superior Walls have their say on it. Without sending an engineer out to assess the situation, SW surmized that it should not be a structural issue. Still, they said that an engineer should come out (hint: at my expense) to determine the cause of the cracks (i.e., to see if SW may be liable), and to determine the appropriate remediation. Ron the builder suspects that, at the very least, some form of lateral bracing will be required, even if it means having to redirect the HVAC supplies, filling the recesses between studs with concrete, etc.

I am not terribly concerned about this. All I know is that somebody else is paying to assess the situation and fix this. Not me. If it isn't an inherent failure of the Superior Walls system, then it's the responsibility of the HVAC contractor. They can fight it out amongst themselves; I'll just ring the bell.

GOOD GOLLY, I NEEDS A LOLLY

Maybe it was all of the heavy glass being staged on the garage roof. Maybe it was the weight of the garage door and motor. But in the end gravity won.

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

The first sign of trouble was the formation of a pond, er, puddle on the roof over the garage after a rainstorm. A pretty deep puddle. At first I assumed that the roof was not pitched sufficiently or that there was perhaps a deficiency of roofing material in that spot. Later, after some investigation, the roofing contractor determined that the LVL in the garage was starting to sag. In a nutshell, it seems that the beam was insufficiently sized to support the entire roof structure to begin with. In hindsight, this should have been a steel beam. But in the interest of saving a few drakmas, we went with an LVL instead. Penny wise, pound foolish indeed. So rather than undergoing the horrific task of replacing it with a steel beam after the fact, a lolly column will be installed to support the LVL. Ugh! I am definitely disappointed with having a column in the garage, but I suppose that is infinitely better than having the entire thing collapse during the next Nor'easter this winter.

ODDS n ENDS (mostly odd)

My mailbox:

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

Ron the builder is convinced that someone is going to a) steal it or b) knock it over with a baseball bat. I guess no matter where you go there will never be a shortage of bored teens.

Break Metal:

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

I didn't think I was going to like this (my heart was set on clear anodized), but I think it adds some depth/contrast to the curtain wall.

Stair Design:

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

No, this is not MY staircase (I wish!), but the new curtain wall contractor is going to take up the challenge of doing an L-shaped design inspired by this cantilevered design. He's a brave, brave man!

Dear OPEC and your $75/barrel oil: Drop dead.

Alternate text shown when the browser is unable to load the image

This page Copyright © LiveModern, Inc. and by the Contributing Author(s) above, if any. Ed. (2006, August 12). Wind in my sails. Retrieved December 01, 2008, from LiveModern: Your Best Modern Home Web site: http://livemodern.com/Members/hejiranyc/blog/wind.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License. Cite/Attribute Resource.

great blog

Posted by Steven at 08-13-2006 11:01

Great informative blog! Thank you for sharing and good luck w/ finishing your project! A true inspiration of perserverance and a good attitude.

Solar question

Posted by Jeffrey Rous at 08-13-2006 15:35

First of all, thanks for the wonderful blog (even though the project itself has not gone as smoothly as you would have liked). Second, I don't recall you having much to say about the solar panels. My research led me to the conclusion that they were not worth the trouble and higher maintenance that I would have liked, but I also remember thinking that most of my hesitation came from the paucity of reliable and consistant information. Is there a type or system of panels that you are using that you would recommend?

Solar

Posted by Ed at 08-13-2006 16:41

The fact is, I would be lying to you if I told you that I spent months and months researching solar photovoltaic systems before having my system installed. That being said, I did look into the pros and cons of various types of solar: hot water, evacuated tubes, passive, etc. before deciding that a PV system was the way to go in my situation. Ultimately, what it all really boiled down to was the fact that I was determined to not have to rely on fossil fuels to heat my home, and that with a geothermal HVAC system, the more free "juice" I had to play with, the better. So PV + geothermal + electric tankless water heating seemed to be the most ideal configuration in my particular situation.

When it came to selecting the specific units for my roof, I pretty much left that up to the solar contractor, who has installed dozens of these systems throughout Long Island. The main considerations were: a) power output per panel, b) panel dimensions, c) roof dimensions. At the time, it seemed that the Sharp 200-watt panel (http://solar.sharpusa.com/files/sol_dow_200W_SS.pdf) seemed to offer the ideal solution for the given space. According to the contractor (and other that I spoke with), Sharp supposedly makes the best panels

While speaking with my solar contractor last week, he mentioned the next advance in solar technology- the flat-mount panel that can be pitched at any angle and does not need to be racked- it can be lain right onto the roof substrate. It's supposed to cost a little more per panel, but this is mitigated by eliminating the cost of the racking system.

I do realize that there will be bigger and better breakthroughs in solar technology in the coming years. But then again, will the current incentives (rebates, tax credits, tax deductions, etc.) still be around then? Will the drop in price be enough to offset the current incentives? Anyway, whether we realize it or not, peak oil is here. It's all downhill from here.

Thanks

Posted by Jeffrey Rous at 08-13-2006 22:37

Thanks for the information. With the type of sun we get down in Dallas, I just cannot help but think solar panels should work out.

those cracks

Posted by Gregory La Vardera at 08-14-2006 07:56

I can't imagine that those cracks in the superior wall panels are due to anything but the breaking away of the interior flange. It may have happened due to the force of the breaking, but I'm thinking it has to do with the cutting of the reinforcing tendon in the top of the panel. That would be directly responsible for a reduction in bending strength of the panel and a resultant crack would run from top to bottom. I don't know the pattern of reinforcing used in the panels, and if nothing was cut then my take is likely not true.

How did that happen? Does the manufacturer advocated this kind of mod to run ductwork? Did somebody speak to them before breaking out the concrete?

rebar madness

Posted by Jeffrey Rous at 08-14-2006 13:11

In the last photo of the foundation it really looks like the HVAC guys cut through some pretty substantial rebar. What were teh HVAC guys thinking? When you cut through one side of a box, you pretty much detroy its structure and that rebar is there for a reason. We had a similar situation where a plumber almost cut through about 4 studs in a row to make room for a hot and a cold line (3/4" diameter each). I guess I am also suprised that SW didn't make a point of making clear the acceptable extent to which their walls could be altered. Especially since they are a non-standard construction system.

Is it 4:20 yet?

Posted by Ed at 08-14-2006 15:41

To be honest I am also puzzled how they were able to break through those two headers. And in addition to rebar we are talking about 5000 psi concrete. An incredible amount of force indeed. The fact is that the HVAC contractor did this on his own without asking anyone about what they were doing. I would have GLADLY framed up a secondary wall to run the ductwork through rather than resorting to this; in fact we had to do this in a couple of areas anyway in order to get around the steel beams in the basement. Otherwise the HVAC contractor has been very proactive and conscientious. At least from what I can tell! In any case, I hope that this can be remediated without too much difficulty.

Sagging beam

Posted by stephen levine at 08-15-2006 10:42

An alternate to the lolly column would be to reinforce the existing beam. This probably needs and engineer for opinion, sizing and detail. Maybe sistering up the existing beam with a similar one with the presumption that there would be adequate bearing on each end. Or adding a steel flitch (usually sandwiched between two wood members). This would be done after shoring up the existing beam to correct the roof drainage and get rid of the sag.

Or have you gone through this exercise already?

Stephen

Options

Posted by Ed at 08-23-2006 15:09

All of the various options were considered, but ultimately it came down to the most straightforward, attainable solution, i.e., cheap and simple. Plus, the logistics of trying to crowbar additional beams into a built structure seemed too daunting. The column is a bummer, but in the grand scheme of things, it's a pittance. Who knows... maybe I'll find another use for it. But fortunately the garage is large enough that it would fit two cars (I only have one!) plus bicycles, kayaks, etc.

garage door question

Posted by Alison Wheeler at 08-22-2006 14:49

Thanks for posting such an interesting blog. Your house is going to be beautiful!

Question: By chance, are you installing a Clopay Avante aluminum/glass garage door? I heard that you might be, and I'm looking into my garage door options. If you are, what do you think of its appearance and functionality?

Thanks again.

Clopay Avante

Posted by Ed at 08-23-2006 15:21

Thanks... I hope the final product lives up to the potential.

The Clopay Avante door is up and I am pretty happy with it so far. That is, once I got over the sticker shock. But that's not to say that it's perfect in every way. For one thing, the "obscured" glass seems a bit chintzy looking with its pebbly texture- I think a door at this price point should have come with better quality standard glazing. I would have preferred the "sandblasted" look, but I believe this option would have tacked on another grand to the price! Another annoying thing is that the door has no exterior handle or manual lock mechanism. Basically the only way to open and close this is with the remote. Also, I am finding that it has a tendency to show dirt really easily. But I hope this is due to the dry, sandy conditions at the work site more than anything else. I will find out soon enough how effective it is at keeping out the weather.

Tell me more about this house!

Posted by Regina at 09-03-2006 04:51
I just ran across the Greenbelt house yesterday and could not believe that you are building one. Can I ask you a way to see the inside of the house
either yours or another that you've seen. Tell me what it's like. Is this the Greenbelt 2? Do you mind telling what you think the cost/square foot would be? I can't seem to see on the web site the size of rooms, etc. Any info is greatly appreciated. Do you think the atrium brings great sun into the house compared to just outside windows? Is the atrium sensible in a snowy climate? Questions, questions....I can't believe you are building this house!!